Third attempt to decide on 300 homes for Gittisham

The Welbeck site on land west of Hayne Lane will be determined by the Planning Inspections Committee (PIC) at EDDC on Friday this week.

The application, which has been both contentious and highly controversial, has been rumbling around for some time. The site was designed as a ‘reserve site’ under the draft Local Plan, meaning that it should not come forward in the plan period (currently to 2026) unless all other attempts to find suitable land in Honiton have failed.

Land west of Hayne with Blackdown Hills AONB in the distance

Land west of Hayne with Blackdown Hills AONB in the distance

The application was first submitted just before Christmas 2013 ( and finally went before the Development Management Committee (EDDC’s planning committee) in early April. Committee members raised concerns about the sustainability of the site and the single access from a country lane under a narrow railway bridge.

Narrow railway bridge under which all traffic will have to pass to enter or leave the proposed estate

Narrow railway bridge under which all traffic will have to pass to enter or leave the proposed estate

It was determined that the decision should be deferred to the Planning Inspections Committee, members of which duly made a site visit on 25 April. On the visit they were accompanied by planning officers from EDDC and a DCC traffic officer, who attempted to allay the fears of members about access to the site.

On returning to EDDC’s offices, the application was approved by members (by 5 votes to 3), not because it was the most suitable site to build on the outskirts of Honiton, but because they did not have robust enough reasons for refusal that would stand up at appeal.

And that, sadly, is how planning decisions are taken in the absence of a Local Plan.

Many (including members of Gittisham Parish Council and me, as ward member) expressed concern about the decision and, following a meeting with members of the Legal Department, planning officers and the Chief Executive, Mark Williams, it was decided that the application would be returned to the Planning Inspections Committee for consideration of the landscape issues. The site sits between two Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and it is the setting of the AONBs which needs to be taken into consideration with this application.

The Planning Inspections Committee reconvened in July (, but as many of the statutory consultees had only just responded to the application, officers recommended that the application be deferred until such time as full consideration had been given to these late reports.

PIC will meet on Friday 5 September at 11 o’clock at the Knowle (EDDC offices) in Sidmouth. The officer recommendation is for approval of the application, but concern is still being raised that due consideration has not been given to all the reports, particularly from those commenting on the landscape value of the site.

But there should be no doubt that none of the angst currently being suffered by those in Gittisham Village, Gittisham Vale and Honiton itself would be felt if EDDC had its Local Plan in place. While the Council can boast happily about the number of appeals it has won, it does not negate the worry and financial cost residents of East Devon are having to face to fight inappropriate development.

Currently, the adoption of the draft Local Plan is scheduled for summer 2015, but there are many hoops to jump through first.

This entry was posted in News and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Third attempt to decide on 300 homes for Gittisham

  1. Paul says:

    As I have commented elsewhere, EDDC’s latest (draft) annual report being considered by Cabinet as I type this, crows about how EDDC has delivered 3x as many “affordable” houses as they committed to. Since affordable houses are effectively a proportion of each major development this 200% extra houses is simply a reflection of the large number of planning approvals being made (like this one) purely due to a lack of an approved Local Plan.

    In the Council’s own plan ( ) they promised to have the Local Plan approved and adopted by 2013. There is (of course) no mention of this in their annual report, and instead their revised plan ( ) has restated the target date as “by 2016”.

    George Orwell would be proud of EDDC’s ability to double-speak – though like the Local Plan EDDC are somewhat late in achieving this (2014 rather than 1984).

  2. Pingback: Great sadness as 300 houses are approved at Planning Inspections Committee | Susie Bond

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s